http://www.itwire.com/content/view/27046/127/by Stan Beer
Tuesday, 18 August 2009
As Asian telecoms service provider Pacnet announces its intention to list on the NASDAQ in 2010, the company's CEO has derided the NBN as commercially unviable and believes the money would be better spent on a high bandwidth submarine cable between Australia and the US.
According to Pacnet CEO William Barney, the Australian Government, like other governments around the world, does not really have much idea about how to make the NBN economically viable.
"I think it's very fluid right now as they're trying to figure out how to build a fibre network that brings low cost content to the consumer," Barney told iTWire."I'm skeptical about whether you can make the economics work in the non urban areas without having a complete government owned loss leading telco because that's essentially what you did in the old days.
"You can't put that in the hands of the private sector because no one will make money doing that. The farmer 100 miles outside of Melbourne is not going to pay you 1000 bucks a month for broadband and that's essentially what it cost you to build it to him.
"Any NBN has got to be government owned and tax payer funded, according to Barney.
"It's the rich funding the poor in many ways, with your urban population funding your rural population."Barney believes there is a much better way to use tax payer funds to improve the broadband experience for Australian consumers.
In terms of broadband content delivery to Australian internet users, Australia should focus on building intercontinental bandwidth rather than the NBN, according to Barney.
"I would argue that you should have a government built cable that goes between Australia and the United States. You might be better served in terms of content delivery if you did that versus building a broadband network to the rural areas. That would be a better $500 million spend," said Barney.
"If the government just built a non-profit cable that would essentially take down the cost structure of the cables by 90%. That would give you affordable access to US content which makes up 50-60% of your broadband cost per consumer."And you could uncap access in the urban areas so essentially you could run a complete video capability to the United States. You could watch sport anywhere in the world. It would change life for the consumer in a dramatic way.
"So why isn't the Australian Government doing it?
"Because I don't think they've even thought about it," said Barney.
"The New Zealand Government is thinking about it but I don't think the Australian Government has even broken down what are the components of broadband and where is the cost that you're actually paying."
And who will actually pay more for what so if you wanted to subsidise something where would you get your biggest bang for your tax payer buck."
A submarine cable would also bring more benefit to most Australian consumers than additional internal fibre infrastructure that urban areas don't really need, according to Barney.
"If you take the average (city) street here, you've probably got five or six fibre runs going down it. Do you actually need another fibre run? Probably not. The issue is 100 miles outside the city where he probably has one low copper run on a telephone pole somewhere near him."
On the issue of an upcoming public listing of Pacnet, Barney said it is likely to happen before the end of 2010 but could even be in the first quarter.
"We're Asia's largest owner of submarine cables, owning two thirds of the cables. We're the largest internet backbone in Asia, we're one of the fastest growing companies and it looks like in 2010 we'll be one of the more exciting listed companies," Barney told iTWire.
The Pacnet IPO has yet to be officially announced but Barney said it will be soon and the listing will be on the NASDAQ."We have just selected our banks and we're getting ready to move forward."So why has Pacnet decided to go public?
"We have no debt and we throw up a lot of cash but we think that in order to move from essentially a 20-30% a year growth company to 50-70% we're going to have to raise a bit of capital that will allow us to do some mergers and acquisitions a lot easier than we've done in the past," said Barney.
"Last year we expanded into China and we're expanding into India and we've announced that we're going into Vietnam."
Another big capital project we've announced is that we're building a cable that will go from Japan all the way to the United States. That will be completed in January and then we're looking at how we can build a cable into India.
"Asia is a big spot. The internet is growing in total users every year at 20% and, if you look at bandwidth consumed, it's growing by more than 40%."